|
Reviews For Down, Down, My Friends; We're Going Home
Reviewer: ineffabird Anonymous
Date: 01/19/08 - 11:45PM
Title: 1/1
Oh, my God. This was- beautiful, if such a word can be allowed for the cicumstances under which it was applied. I applaud your language, the telling of the story backwards, te tempo, i can't even describe it really without going into the language of songs or poetry. I can feel from this every emotion you were trying to convey. That's surely what you were going for, wasn't it? Beautiful. Forgive me my incoherant rantings. The only thing i could possibly even mention, just as a little thing, honest criticism you know- the very last part, #5. It didn't really seem to fit the rest of the piece. It's...oddly jaunty, as though Hakkai's moved out of being broken into a brittle little sanity that'll last him long enough to finish things. That wouldn't necessarily be inaccurate, but i fund it odd and slightly out of character for Sanzo to have given Hakka the means to his end. I can't see Sanzo letting him give up. But it raps everything up very nicely, which is after all the purpose of an end, and add a nice little touch of horror once one has read the entire story and can see what he's talking about.
Reviewer: zan Signed
Date: 03/13/06 - 10:49AM
Title: 1/1
Ok think me strange if you like, but this is one of two fics I've read backwards and that it makes sense still. Brilliant. The paraphrasing is done so well. so cleverly. Can you tell? I. Love. Your. Writing! |